Navigating Immigration Campus Concerns Under Trump: A Brief for University Administrators

Introduction

Immigration policies under the Trump administration will pose significant challenges for universities in supporting international and undocumented students, faculty, and staff. To help universities navigate this, the American Council on Education’s (ACE) has prepared a new issue brief which provides guidance for navigating this evolving immigration landscape. The brief examines policy changes such as stricter visa rules, increased border scrutiny, and potential threats to programs like DACA and TPS, highlighting their impact on campus communities. 

We have put together a summary of ACE’s recommendations to help our partnered universities effectively support their communities during this time of uncertainty. For an in-depth exploration of these topics, administrators are encouraged to consult the original American Council on Education’s Issue Brief here.

Immigration Basics and Visa Types

1. What are the most common visa types for international students and faculty?

• F-1 Visa: Predominantly issued to international students pursuing full-time academic programs, the F-1 visa imposes stringent requirements for maintaining status. Students are limited to on-campus employment or authorized practical training programs such as Curricular Practical Training (CPT) or Optional Practical Training (OPT). Noncompliance with these restrictions can result in severe consequences, including loss of legal status.
• J-1 Visa: This visa category facilitates cultural exchange and is often utilized by visiting scholars and exchange students. J-1 holders may face two-year home residency requirements upon completion of their programs, a stipulation that can complicate their professional and academic trajectories.
• H-1B Visa: Commonly held by faculty and researchers in specialized fields, the H-1B visa is subject to annual numerical caps and increasingly stringent adjudication processes. These limitations pose significant barriers to recruitment and retention of global talent.
• O-1 Visa: Reserved for individuals of extraordinary ability or achievement, the O-1 visa necessitates extensive documentation of professional excellence. This category is particularly relevant for distinguished academics and researchers.

2. What is TPS, and how does it impact campus communities? 

Temporary Protected Status (TPS) grants temporary work authorization and protection from deportation to individuals from designated countries experiencing crises. While this program provides a lifeline for affected individuals, its temporary nature and susceptibility to policy changes create uncertainties for students and staff reliant on TPS. Universities must offer robust support mechanisms, including legal counseling and advocacy for alternative pathways to stability.

3. Why is DACA significant for campus populations? 

DACA provides temporary relief from deportation and work authorization to undocumented individuals brought to the U.S. as children. Despite its critical role in enabling these individuals to pursue higher education and contribute to campus life, DACA remains mired in legal challenges. This precarious status exacerbates stress among recipients, underscoring the importance of targeted mental health resources and institutional advocacy.

4. How do discretionary immigration categories affect campuses? 

Discretionary immigration categories, such as humanitarian parole and asylum, allow individuals to work and reside in the U.S. without conferring formal legal status. These categories often entail protracted uncertainty, requiring universities to provide comprehensive legal resources and facilitate access to external support networks to address the unique vulnerabilities of these individuals.

Privacy and Campus Safety

5. Are student records protected from immigration enforcement? 

FERPA (Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act) safeguards student records from unauthorized disclosure. Universities are legally obligated to withhold such information unless presented with a valid subpoena or warrant. Institutions must regularly audit their data management practices to ensure FERPA compliance and mitigate potential risks associated with data breaches or unauthorized disclosures.

6. Can immigration enforcement agencies enter campuses? 

Under the Department of Homeland Security’s "sensitive location" policy, ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) typically refrains from conducting enforcement activities on campuses. However, this policy is not codified in law and may be subject to change. Access to restricted areas, such as residence halls or private offices, requires a judicial warrant or explicit consent. Universities should develop and disseminate clear protocols for managing such scenarios.

7. How does government oversight of visa programs impact universities? 

Federal agencies, including ICE and the Department of State, conduct unannounced site visits to verify compliance with visa program regulations for F-1, J-1, and H-1B holders. These inspections assess documentation accuracy and institutional adherence to program requirements. Universities must maintain meticulous records and designate specialized personnel to handle these interactions.

Employment and Travel Challenges

8. What employment challenges do international students face?

• F-1 Employment Restrictions: Students on F-1 visas are permitted to work only under narrowly defined circumstances, such as on-campus jobs or approved practical training programs. Violations can lead to the immediate termination of visa status, jeopardizing students' academic progress.
• OPT Processing Delays: Delays in the adjudication of OPT applications frequently disrupt employment plans, creating financial and professional hardships. Universities should advocate for regulatory reforms to streamline processing timelines and offer pre-emptive support to affected students.
• Dependent Visa Limitations: Spouses and dependents on F-2 visas are generally ineligible for employment, which can impose significant financial constraints on international families. Institutions should explore avenues for extending financial aid or creating tailored support programs for these individuals.

9. Are there risks for international students traveling abroad? 

International travel presents multiple risks for students, including:

• Visa Renewal Delays: Students may encounter prolonged delays during consular processing, potentially disrupting their academic or professional obligations.
• Border Inspections: CBP (Customs and Border Protection) officers are authorized to search electronic devices without prior notice. Universities should educate students on safeguarding sensitive data and preparing for such inspections.
• Travel Restrictions: Geopolitical considerations, including country-specific travel bans, may impede reentry for affected students. Institutions must provide timely guidance and legal resources to navigate these barriers.

Legal Risks and Compliance

10. What are the risks for students participating in protests? 

International students engaging in protests risk significant legal repercussions, including:

• Visa Status Revocation: Arrests or university disciplinary actions stemming from protest activities may result in the termination of F-1 or J-1 status. Students must be apprised of these risks and encouraged to seek legal counsel before participating in high-risk activities.
• Heightened Surveillance: Activism on politically sensitive issues may attract scrutiny from federal agencies, necessitating proactive legal and counseling support from universities.

11. Can universities refuse to cooperate with immigration enforcement? 

While public universities are legally bound to comply with federal immigration laws, they retain the right to:

• Require ICE agents to present judicial warrants for access to private areas.
• Establish internal protocols that prioritize student privacy and minimize institutional liability. Transparent communication of these policies is critical to building trust within the campus community.

Additional Questions and Concerns Addressed

12. How do sanctuary campus policies affect immigration enforcement? 

Sanctuary campus designations aim to limit institutional cooperation with federal immigration authorities. However, these policies must align with federal and state regulations to avoid jeopardizing funding eligibility. Universities should balance their advocacy efforts with pragmatic compliance strategies to safeguard both institutional interests and student welfare.

13. How can universities support undocumented students?

• Legal Advocacy: Establish partnerships with immigration attorneys and non-profits to provide free or low-cost legal services.
• Financial Support: Develop institutional funding mechanisms that bypass reliance on federal financial aid.
• Mental Health Resources: Tailor counseling services to address the unique stressors experienced by undocumented students and their families.

14. What steps should administrators take during government site visits?

• Designate a single point of contact to manage interactions with federal agencies.
• Train staff to identify and respond appropriately to administrative versus judicial warrants.
• Maintain detailed records of visa compliance while minimizing unnecessary data collection.

15. Are family members of international students affected by enforcement actions?

Undocumented family members of international students may face deportation, creating emotional and financial instability. Universities should implement comprehensive support plans, including access to emergency resources and legal assistance.

Best Practices for Universities

1. Develop Comprehensive Policies: Establish clear guidelines for handling immigration enforcement actions and ensure that staff are adequately trained.
2. Enhance Communication: Regularly update the campus community on policy developments and institutional responses to emerging challenges.
3. Expand Support Services: Augment existing resources with specialized programs for legal, financial, and mental health assistance.
4. Promote Inclusivity: Cultivate a campus culture that values diversity and actively supports international students and scholars.
5. Engage Policymakers: Advocate for immigration reforms that align with the educational mission of higher education institutions.
6. Prepare for Uncertainty: Develop contingency plans to address sudden policy shifts and mitigate their impact on campus operations.

Conclusion

The Trump administration’s immigration policies have underscored the need for universities to adopt proactive and comprehensive strategies to support their international communities. By addressing regulatory complexities, providing targeted resources, and fostering an inclusive environment, higher education institutions can navigate these challenges while advancing their mission of academic excellence and global engagement. 

Continued vigilance and adaptability will be essential as the immigration landscape evolves. For an in-depth exploration of these topics, administrators are encouraged to consult the original American Council on Education’s Issue Brief.

{{cta}}